« Iraqi Perspectives Project - Part II | Main | Iraqi Perspectives Project - Part IV »
March 29, 2006
Iraqi Perspectives Project - Part III
In this part we learn how Saddam Hussein wrecked the ability of the Iraqi Army to put up an effective defense of their country.
The Iraqi Perspectives project is "an unclassified historical report in book form on the Iraqi view of coalition military operations conducted in Iraq." Published in book form by the U.S. Joint Forces Command’s Joint Center for Operational Analysis, the project examines "the perspectives of the Iraqi civilian and military leadership involved in major combat operations gathered through interviews conducted during the fall and winter of 2003/2004, and an extensive review of Iraqi historical documents done in the months since then."
You can download the report here. It is 230 pages and about 7.5Mb.
This series will summarize the report chapter by chapter. I will provide commentary at the end of each part.
Previous Posts
Iraqi Perspectives Project summary
Iraqi Perspectives Project - Part II - Introduction and Chapter I, The Nature of the Regime
CHAPTER II SKEWED STRATEGY
• Up until the actual invasion occurred, Saddam believed it would not happen. To Saddam, the most important military event that occurred when he was ruler was not the Gulf War, but his war with Iran. He lost hundreds of thousands in that war, and after between it and the revolt by the Shi’a in southern Irar after the Gulf war, he was deeply suspicious and fearful of Iran. To him, then, Iran was the primary enemy.
• “After the 1991 Shi’a and Kurd uprisings Saddam gave his armed forces three priorities: first, secure the regime; second, prepare to handle regional threats; and third, defend against another attack by and American-led Coalition. Thereafter, only the air defense forces received significant resources in order to address the external threat.
• “Saddam always viewed Iran as the primary external threat, followed by Israel and then Turkey.”
• By 2002 Saddam knew we were trying to contact his generals to secure their cooperation in case we invaded. Because of this, he again turned up his internal repression, which had the effect of reducing the effectiveness of his military.
• Saddam set up an intricate and complicated set of organizations which spent their time spying on each other. Some even developed paramilitary capabilities. Saddam’s primary objective was to prevent a coup, and everything in this vast bureaucracy was devoted to this goal. His security restrictions severely degraded the military’s ability to defend the country from external threats. For example, because Saddam believed that officers might plot against him, units were forbidden to communicate directly with each other. In another example is that only a few units were allowed to have maps of Baghdad.
• The primary reason why Saddam thought that the United States would not attack with ground forces was his faith that Russia and France would intervene on his behalf. Their economic interests in his country, he believed, was so great that they would use their vetoes in the Security Council to prevent US action.
• Saddam knew how much the US relied on, indeed believe in, the power and effectiveness of air power. He also knew how much we hated American casualties. He therefore thought that we would hit him with air strikes on 2003 but there would be no ground invasion.
• Worst case, Saddam thought we might occupy southern Iraq. He held onto this view well into OIF (Operation Iraqi Freedom).
My Take
A western reader comes away with an overwhelming sense of waste and inefficiency after reviewing this chapter. We often or usually regard our own governments as inept in many respects, but they are models of perfection compared to that of Ba'athist Iraq. We didn't so much defeat the Iraqi military as did Saddam.
To a large extent I can understand Saddam's belief that we would not invade. After all, we "ran way" after taking what were to him insignificant casualties in Vietnam, Beirut, and Somalia. We could have easily gone all the way to Baghdad at the end of the Gulf War but did not.
But while this may have made sense in the 1990s, it no longer held true after September 11. As was made clear in Chapter I (Part II of this series), Saddam never understood the impact that day had on Americans.
Further, once resolution 1441 passed the Security Council in November of 2002, only someone completely deluded could not see that the Americans were serious this time. Yet Saddam would still not come clean with his WMD programs. It is clear now that all he had to do was open up completely, and all inspectors would find (at least in late 2002/early 2003) was ready-to-go production facilities; bad, but not a caus belli.
If World War II was, as Churchill said, the most preventable war in history, then the Operation Iraqi Freedom was the most telegraphed. Yet Saddam refused to believe the evidence mounting before his eyes. And now he is on trial for his life, which is just where he belongs.
Posted by Tom at March 29, 2006 08:13 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://theredhunter.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/625



