How Federal Regulations Are Created

how are federal regulations made

Trying to work out how are federal regulations made? Congress gives agencies authority, then agencies propose a rule, take public comment and publish a final one. Here is each step.

For wider background on how government decisions are made, see this site’s coverage of public policy explained.

Item Value
Typical minimum public comment period At least 30 days
Usual range of comment periods 30 to 90 days
Earliest effective date of a final rule At least 30 days after Federal Register publication
Executive order governing review of significant rules Executive Order 12866 (issued 1993)
Economic effect that can make a rule “significant” At least $100 million
Usual length of White House review Generally within 90 days

These figures come from the Congressional Research Service overview of federal rulemaking and Harvard’s step-by-step guide to agency rulemaking. They can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Where agencies get the power to write rules

Every regulation starts with a law. According to the Office of the Federal Register’s guide, agencies get their statutory authority to issue regulations from laws enacted by Congress, and in some cases the President may delegate existing Presidential authority to an agency.

The Congressional Research Service (CRS) notes that regulations issued under that authority can carry the force and effect of law. Congress delegates partly because agencies possess significant technical expertise and can establish the details of programs that Congress created in statute.

Delegation has critics as well as defenders. CRS says a commonly cited concern is that the agency personnel who write regulations are not as directly accountable to the electorate as Members of Congress, and that agencies may issue rules inconsistent with congressional intent. It adds that the more precise a statute is, the less discretion an agency has.

The Harvard guide adds that while rulemaking authority comes from Congress, the president sets priorities for agencies, often through Executive Orders. Laws themselves, including spending laws, begin in Congress, and the guide to how does the federal budget process work covers one major example.

How does an agency decide to start a rule?

Sometimes Congress passes a law that directs an agency to act and even sets a schedule. The Federal Register guide says it is more common for an agency to survey its area of legal responsibility and choose its own priorities.

Factors an agency may weigh include:

  • New technologies or new data on existing issues
  • Concerns arising from accidents or other problems affecting society
  • Recommendations from congressional committees or federal advisory committees
  • Petitions from interest groups, corporations and members of the public
  • Lawsuits filed by interest groups, corporations, States and members of the public
  • Presidential directives and studies by agency staff

Agencies also tell the public what is coming. The same guide says they must publish a Regulatory Plan once a year in the fall and an Agenda of Regulatory and Deregulatory Actions in the spring and fall, together known as the Unified Agenda.

Early on, an agency may publish an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to gather information. Some agencies also use negotiated rulemaking, inviting interested groups to try to reach consensus on the terms of a proposed rule.

The three basic steps of notice and comment

Most regulations are created through what the Northwestern Pritzker law library guide calls “informal rulemaking” or notice-and-comment rulemaking, which has three basic steps. CRS explains that Section 553 of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is the default procedure unless an agency’s own statute provides different ones.

  1. Notice. The agency publishes a notice of proposed rulemaking in the Federal Register, naming its legal authority and the terms or subject of the proposed rule.
  2. Comment. Interested persons can comment, and most agencies mainly collect comments on Regulations.gov.
  3. Final rule. The agency publishes the final rule with a concise general statement of its basis and purpose and its responses to public comments.

On timing, CRS says an agency typically provides at least 30 days for public comment. The Harvard guide says the comment period usually lasts from 30 to 90 days, and that the APA does not mandate a specific length.

The same Harvard guide notes that Executive Order 12866 recommends a comment period of no less than 60 days. It also says courts expect agencies to respond to significant comments, and the final rule must be a “logical outgrowth” of the proposal.

A final rule generally takes effect later, not at once. According to CRS, it may not go into effect until at least 30 days after publication in the Federal Register, with certain exceptions.

how are federal regulations made Document bundles
A person in a dark suit carries a tall stack of brown folders tied with string.

What does White House review add?

Centralized review is a layer on top of the APA. CRS traces it to 1981, when President Ronald Reagan’s Executive Order 12291 set up review through the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) in the Office of Management and Budget. In 1993, President Bill Clinton’s Executive Order 12866 replaced that order but left much of the process intact.

As of CRS’s July 15, 2026 update, Executive Order 12866 still remains in effect as amended. Agencies send their “significant” proposed and final rules to OIRA before publication, and for economically significant rules they must conduct a cost-benefit analysis.

The Harvard guide says a rule is significant if the agency or OIRA finds it is likely to do any of the following:

  • Affect the economy by at least $100 million
  • Create inconsistency with, or interfere with, another agency’s actions
  • Alter entitlements, grants, user fees or loan programs, or the rights of their recipients
  • Raise novel legal or policy issues

The same guide says OIRA review is generally completed within 90 days, though some reviews are shorter or longer. CRS adds that various Presidents have made further changes to the process through their own policies, often asking OIRA to carry them out.

When can agencies skip notice and comment?

Not every agency action goes through the full process. CRS lists exceptions for certain rules, including:

  • Guidance documents, such as interpretive rules and general statements of policy
  • Matters affecting agency management or personnel
  • Matters relating to public property, loans, grants, benefits or contracts
  • Matters that constitute a military or foreign affairs function of the United States

An agency may also go straight to a final rule if a full process is “impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to the public interest.” Trade measures such as those in the explainer on how do tariffs work follow their own legal routes, and this guide does not cover them.

How federal regulations are checked, changed or undone

Congress keeps oversight of the rules it has authorized. As summarized in the July 2026 CRS update, Congress can expand or contract agency authority, repeal existing rules, compel an agency to issue rules, or change the procedures agencies must follow. It can also use the Congressional Review Act to overturn rules through a joint resolution of disapproval.

Courts are a second check. CRS says the APA creates a strong presumption of judicial review of final agency action, and a court may vacate a rule if the agency acted:

  • Arbitrarily or capriciously
  • In excess of its statutory authority
  • Contrary to a constitutional right
  • In violation of procedures required by statute

Undoing a rule is not a shortcut. The Harvard guide, published in January 2025, says the process an agency uses to undo a rule must generally be identical to the process used to issue it.

Frequently asked questions

Is a rule the same thing as a regulation?

Show answer

In practice, yes. The Office of the Federal Register’s guide says it uses the terms “rule” and “regulation” interchangeably.

How can I find out which rules an agency plans to write?

Show answer

Agencies announce future rulemaking in the Unified Agenda, which the Federal Register guide says is posted on RegInfo.gov and Regulations.gov. Proposed rules themselves appear in the Federal Register.

Can the public comment on a proposed rule?

Show answer

Yes. The APA requires agencies to allow interested persons an opportunity to comment, and CRS says most agencies mainly collect comments on Regulations.gov.

Can a court throw out a federal regulation?

Show answer

It can, on specific grounds. A court may vacate a rule if the agency acted arbitrarily or capriciously, beyond its statutory authority, contrary to a constitutional right, or in violation of required procedures, according to CRS.

Can Congress overturn a rule?

Show answer

Yes. The CRS update of July 2026 says Congress can use the Congressional Review Act to overturn rules through a joint resolution of disapproval, or change the underlying statute.