Public Policy: Balanced Explainers on Major Issues

public policy explained

Lost in budget headlines? Public policy explained simply: many US debates turn on how Congress sets spending, handles debt and funds programs. You can follow them by learning a few recurring steps and reports.

Item Value
CBO Budget and Economic Outlook horizon Ten years
CBO Long-Term Budget Outlook horizon 25 or 75 years
Reconciliation process created Budget Act of 1974
Trustees’ reports on Social Security and Medicare Annual
Extraordinary measures hold off debt ceiling action A few months at a time
Recurring budget reports summarized by CRFB Published since 2009

These figures come from the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget’s recurring reports page. Budget rules, report schedules and projections can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

How the federal budget fits together

The federal budget is not one decision. It is a set of separate processes, and knowing which one is in the news explains most of the confusion. If you want the full walk-through, read how does the federal budget process work for the step-by-step version.

The first piece is appropriations: annual decisions made by Congress about how the federal government spends some of its money. In general, this process covers the discretionary portion of the budget, which ranges from national defense to food safety to education to federal employee salaries.

The second piece is mandatory spending, which appropriations leave out. Programs such as Medicare and Social Security are spent automatically according to formulas, so they follow different rules.

public policy explained Team gesture
Several people bring their fists together above a desk with notebooks and electronic devices.

A third piece is reconciliation, a special legislative process created as part of the Budget Act of 1974. It is intended to help lawmakers make the tax and mandatory spending changes necessary to meet the levels proposed in the congressional budget resolution.

  • Discretionary spending: set through the annual appropriations process.
  • Mandatory spending: paid automatically by formula, as with Medicare and Social Security.
  • Reconciliation: a route for tax and mandatory spending changes tied to the budget resolution.

Reports that track the numbers

Much policy debate rests on a handful of regular reports. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) has published summaries and analysis of them since 2009, which makes its list a handy map of what to watch.

  • CBO’s Budget and Economic Outlook: projects trends for spending and revenue for the next ten years.
  • CBO’s Long-Term Budget Outlook: takes a longer view, focusing on the next 25 or 75 years.
  • Social Security Trustees’ Report: an annual report on the health of the Social Security trust funds.
  • Medicare Trustees’ Report: an annual report on the health of the Medicare trust funds.
  • Analysis of the President’s Budget: a yearly look at the administration’s proposal.

Every piece of legislation is estimated for how it would change the CBO’s ten-year projections. CRFB describes the Congressional Budget Office as a vital part of the budget process because of this scoring and forecasting role. That is one organization’s view, but it explains why CBO numbers appear in so many debates.

public policy explained Document storage
Open binders filled with thick stacks of paper sit on a shelf.

Debt, the debt ceiling and shutdowns in public policy

Debt is measured in more than one way. CRFB publishes an explainer on gross debt versus debt held by the public because the different measures of debt tell you different things about the government’s fiscal situation. To start with the basics, see what is the national debt.

The debt ceiling is a separate issue. It must be raised from time to time when either the overall limit is reached or a suspension has ended, and what is the debt ceiling covers it in detail.

While Congress has not acted, the Treasury Department often uses accounting tools called extraordinary measures to avoid defaulting on the government’s obligations. According to CRFB, these measures can only hold off action for a few months at a time. Once that window closes, the President and Congress have to agree on some form of relief from the limit, and without it the government risks default.

Shutdowns follow a different trigger. If lawmakers do not pass legislation to fund federal programs by the time their funding lapses, the federal government will shut down.

Two views on debt ceiling fights

CRFB says failing to increase the debt ceiling would be dangerous and self-defeating. It also says it would be a mistake not to use the opportunity to address the country’s mounting debt burden. In 2011, President Obama and leaders of both chambers of Congress engaged in high-level negotiations in the hopes of agreeing on a deficit reduction package to attach to any debt ceiling increase.

Those are the views of one budget-focused group, not a settled consensus. Other analysts and lawmakers weigh the trade-offs differently, so it helps to read several sources.

Programs that run on formulas

Social Security and Medicare are the clearest examples of mandatory spending. Because they are paid out automatically by formula, they do not go through the annual appropriations process in the same way.

Each has an annual trustees’ report on trust fund health, and those reports often drive headlines. For program basics, see how does social security work and how does medicare work.

More pieces of the policy picture

Budgets are only part of public policy. Rules, trade and monetary policy shape daily life too, and each has its own explainer on this site.

public policy explained Office discussion
Two men in suits sit at a table with papers and a small blue flag.

For wider context, read us news explained for domestic developments. For events abroad, try world news explained.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between discretionary and mandatory spending?

Show answer

Discretionary spending is decided in the annual appropriations process and ranges from national defense to education. Mandatory spending, such as Medicare and Social Security, is spent automatically according to formulas.

What does the CBO’s Budget and Economic Outlook cover?

Show answer

It projects trends for spending and revenue for the next ten years. The Long-Term Budget Outlook looks further ahead, at the next 25 or 75 years.

What happens if the debt ceiling is not raised?

Show answer

According to CRFB, the Treasury can use extraordinary measures to avoid default, but only for a few months at a time. After that, Congress and the President must sign debt ceiling relief or otherwise face default.

What causes a government shutdown?

Show answer

A shutdown happens if lawmakers do not pass legislation to fund federal programs by the time their funding lapses.